Gluten Free Pie Recipes

What are the four kinds of pie?

Traditionally there are four kinds of pie:

• Fruit pies – fruit is combined with sugar and a thickener, then baked in a crust. They can be topped with a second crust, a crumb topping, or left open.
• Custard pies – these have a custard base is made from eggs and usually a form of dairy and then baked in the crust. This includes not only a traditional creamy custard but also pumpkin and sweet potato pie, as well as, surprisingly, pecan and other nut pies.
• Cream pies – cream pies typically have a bottom crust filled with a custard or pudding that can be homemade or made from a mix before pouring into the crust. Unlike custard pies, they are chilled to set, not baked, and are usually topped with whipped cream.
• Savory – this typically means something along the lines of a pot pie with a top and bottom crust and a savory stew-like filling, or a single crust quiche. And while technically a casserole, we can throw Shepherds Pie into the mix too.

What are the different types of crust for pie? 

Some people might prefer the traditional pastry pie crust. However, there is always debate about butter versus shortening, making it by hand versus using a food processor, or even buying it pre-made from the store.

If you are making a gluten-free pie, start with this perfectly flaky pie crust. Then try one of these recipes or fill it with Apple Pie Filling or Cherry Pie Filling.

Others prefer a graham cracker crust or one made from another cookie like gluten free vanilla wafers. It’s even possible to swap out that cookie crust for an almond meal crust if you need a gluten free option.

Your pie possibilities are endless. So whether you prefer traditional pie recipes and stick to the classics or want to try something new and creative, you are sure to find something you’ll love in this amazing list of the best pie recipes!

Gluten Free Custard Pies

Yes, your classic pumpkin pie falls into this category, but there are many more ideas that you’ve never considered before.

Gluten Free Lemon Meringue Pie

This Gluten Free Lemon Meringue Pie features a sweet-tart, silky smooth filling balanced on a buttery gluten free crust capped with a pillow of meringue. It is so easy to make at home and tastes like it came from a bakery!

Get The Recipe

Gluten Free Cream Pies

The most heavenly of pies with a creamy pudding filling in a flaky or crumb crust, and topped with clouds of pillowy whipped cream.

Gluten Free S’Mores Pudding Pie

You don't need a campfire to make this easy treat. Made with decadent Hershey's Milk Chocolate pudding in a gluten-free graham cracker crust, topped with fluffy toasted marshmallow meringue.

Get The Recipe