This post may contain affiliate links. Read my disclosure policy.
This decadent Nutella Brownie Ice Cream starts with a simple base of no-churn cheesecake ice cream that is loaded with crumbled brownies and swirls of chocolate hazelnut spread. It’s so easy to make and you don’t even need an ice cream maker. All of the sweetest people in your life will love a scoop (or three)!
Easy Brownie Ice Cream Recipe with Nutella
This decadent Nutella Brownie Ice Cream is definitely a happy accident. I ended up with a batch of overbaked brownies. Not inedible, but not quite as gooey and fudgy as I like. So what was the solution to avoid tossing a pan of chocolaty goodness in the trash?
Turn it into ice cream! Yes, a fully-loaded ice cream. Because if it is full of ribbons and swirls and chunks and bits, you can bet I am all over it.
So the next time you overbake your brownies, or even if you bake them perfectly but only end up eating about half the pan just mix them into a simple batch of no-churn cheesecake ice cream. Then add a swirl of Nutella for good measure. Because there aren’t many things that aren’t made better when you add thick chocolate hazelnut spread.
Why this Recipe Works
Seriously, I have no words for why this brownie ice cream is so amazing!
OK, I have a few words. It starts with a base of no-churn ice cream. That means you don’t need to separate eggs and cook and churn and freeze. It’s all a matter of whipping cream and folding in some sweetened condensed milk. Only here, I added cream cheese to give it that richness of cheesecake with a tangy flavor that balance all of that sweet chocolate goodness.
And it has swirls and chunks and ribbons of brownie gooeyness. It really is the perfect way to salvage some overbaked brownies, or maybe even some that have been sitting around for a few days and are starting to dry out. They will absorb moisture and get all fudgy again.
Plus, you can use any brownies you like. Make a batch of your favorite homemade brownies, like my super fudgy Gluten Free Brownies. Double down on the flavors in the ice cream by using Flourless Nutella Cheesecake Brownies. Add an extra element of chocolate chip cookies by using Gluten Free Brookies. Use your favorite box mix. Or if you are separate to make the ice cream recipe but don’t want to deal with baking, pick up a pan of brownies at the grocery store!
The ice cream base itself only has four ingredients, then you just need your brownies and a jar of chocolate hazelnut spread to make this epic Nutella brownie cheesecake ice cream.
- Cream cheese: You can use regular or light, just make sure it is softened to room temperature so that it blends in smoothly. I do not recommend fat free cream cheese.
- Sweetened condensed milk: One can, and regular or fat free will work.
- Heavy cream: Make sure it is well-chilled.
- Pure vanilla extract
- Prepared brownies: You’ll need about half a pan, or as much as you like. They can be homemade or from a box mix, and regular or gluten free.
- Nutella: Or your favorite chocolate hazelnut spread. You can even make homemade Nutella.
How to Make Brownie Ice Cream
Preparations: Start by placing a large glass or metal bowl in the fridge or freezer. Having a chilled bowl helps the cream to whip better.
Make the ice cream base: Using an electric mixer or whisk attachment, beat together the cream cheese and sweetened condensed milk until smooth. Then in the chilled bowl, beat the heavy cream and vanilla to soft peaks. Gently fold the cream cheese mixture into the whipped cream.
Add the mix-ins: Crumble about half of the pan of brownies (more or less, as desired) into to cream mixture, top with small dollops of Nutella, and gently fold in to create brownie and Nutella swirls.
Freeze: Pour the mixture into a container that you can freeze and has an airtight lid, cover, and place in the freezer for 4-6 hours or until frozen.
Now enjoy a bowl or no-churn brownie ice cream, or scoop some over more brownies and add hot fudge and whipped cream to make the ultimate brownie sundae!
How long can you store no-churn ice cream?
If you keep it sealed in an airtight container or tightly wrapped with plastic wrap, this ice cream should stay good for up to two months. Wrapping it well to keep out air and moisture will help prevent freezer burn. Freezer burn does not make it unsafe to eat, but it may affect the texture or flavor.
Things you’ll need
- A large metal bowl is the best thing for making no-churn ice cream because, unlike plastic, you can make the bowl cold which helps the cream whip better.
- A hand mixer with a whisk attachment is my preference to make it quicker and easier to whip the cream.
- Get a good spatula is needed for folding everything together.
- You can use a freezer-safe storage container with a lid, but I find these no-churn ice cream recipes always fit nicely into a 9-inch loaf pan.
Nutella Brownie Cheesecake No-Churn Ice Cream
- 8 oz. cream cheese (regular or light), softened to room temperature
- 14.5 oz. can of sweetened condensed milk (regular or fat free)
- one pint heavy cream, well chilled
- 1 tsp pure vanilla extract
- About half of a pan of prepared brownies, homemade or from a box mix (can be regular or gluten free)
- 1/3 cup Nutella or your favorite chocolate hazelnut spread
- Place a large glass or metal bowl in the refrigerator or freezer for whipping the cream.
- Using an electric mixer or whisk attachment, beat together the cream cheese and sweetened condensed milk until smooth. Set aside.
- In the chilled bowl, using an electric mixer or whisk, combine the heavy cream and vanilla, and beat to soft peaks.
- Gently fold the cream cheese mixture into the whipped cream.
- Crumble about half of the pan of brownies (more or less, as desired) into to cream mixture, top with small dollops of Nutella, and gently fold in to create brownie and Nutella swirls.
- Pour the mixture into a container that you can freeze and has an airtight lid, cover, and place in the freezer for 4-6 hours or until frozen.
Oh my yum. Looks amazing!! Thanks so much for sharing at our Best Of The Weekend party, as always! Pinning this to our party board. Have a great weekend! xo
Thanks so much!
Yum I can’t wait to give this a shot!!!
Oh do it! It is so amazing!
I’ve made condensed milk, no-churn ice cream before, but never with cream cheese. Neat idea! I’m always on the lookout for ice cream recipes that don’t require appliances I don’t own!
So many things you can do with the no-churn base, and cream cheese adds a unique element!
Online friends, friends I met and that I now communicate with online…there are so many wonderful people in the world and yay for being able to stay in touch even a million miles away. Nutella AND brownie!? You’re my kinda gal!
I know, have family that lives far away, and they love getting “real time” updates on my kids! Yes, Nutella AND Brownie AND Cheesecake AND Ice Cream! 🙂
No churn? I’m in!
I know! Exactly!
Yay for foodie friends! Brianne, this ice cream looks amazing. I’ve been waiting to see this since you shared the idea on Facebook. I love it!
Thanks Jennie! So glad I had some help with this idea!
Usually when a recipe fails, I make truffles, but I like the idea of putting the brownies into ice cream much better. Pair it with Nutella? Heaven.
Hmmm, may have to screw up some more brownies and make truffles 🙂
Yes to everything! I haven’t made ice cream in so long, I think this needs to be my next batch. Also we are so glad to have you with us!
I know, it was totally time to make some more ice cream!
I think ice cream is really the perfect treat and the flavors in this one are WONDERFUL, what a great treat for a Valentine!
Thanks so much Diane! Ice cream is a favorite of my hubby and I.
Don’t you just love when deliciousness is born of mistakes? 🙂
I’d most like to try the key lime pie cuties, the mango cheesecake ice cream sounds like an interesting flavor combo.
This looks purely delicious! I’m always looking for good ice cream recipes 🙂 I especially like one with little cookie or cake bits.
I know, I love “stuff” in my ice cream!
I completely agree on the fabulousness of the food blogger community. We are there for each other in good times and bad, help each other, inspire each other, and so much more. I’m so glad the community gave you the inspiration for this incredible ice cream. It’s one where I think the whole batch is one serving (or at least only for one – as in me – to enjoy for days).
I agree with everything you said!! Including about me eating all of the ice cream for days!
Yum!! Nothing better than chocolate except maybe chocolate and ice cream! This sounds amazing!
I love it with a “fail” turns out to be the best thing that you can have on hang for another recipes. This ice-cream looks amazing and I hope you’ll share the recipe for nutella brownies in the future as well
Oooh, I did, I did! They ended up awesome – https://cupcakesandkalechips.com/flourless-nutella-cheesecake-swirl-brownies/
Welcome to the Holiday Food Party group, Brianne! Isn’t this so much fun? You picked a heck of an amazing dish for your first post. This looks ah-may-zing. I can (and do) eat ice cream year round so staring at your beautiful photos is making my mouth water. And I’m craving ice cream right now like you wouldn’t believe. I love our food blogging community too – it’s been such a blast getting to meet incredible talented ladies like the one in our group and beyond. I’m glad people were able to inspire you to use your Nutella brownie. SUCH a brilliant idea putting it into ice cream and seriously, this no churn recipe is the best!
I seriously am so excited to join you guys, Nancy! This no churn ice cream is so awesome and frightening at the same time, because it is wayyy too easy!
Yum! No churn and killer ingredients!! Yay for ice cream!
This no-churn ice cream may be the death of me 😉
Omg really…Nutella, brownies, AND cheesecake all in ice cream?!?!? I die.
This looks heavenly! I could so get in trouble with this in my freezer.
I’ve been trying to forget that it is in there… at least until this weekend!
All my favorite Valentine’s flavors in ONE ice cream!!! This looks fabulous…I’ll take 3 scoops 🙂
I know! How can you go wrong?